Primary vs Secondary Immune Response- 12 Differences
Updated:
B cells are a type of white blood cell that play a vital role in the adaptive immune system. They are responsible for producing antibodies, which are proteins that can bind to specific antigens (foreign substances) and neutralize them. B cells can also present antigens to other immune cells, such as T cells, and activate them to mount a coordinated response.
B cells develop in the bone marrow from hematopoietic stem cells. They undergo a process of maturation and selection, where they express different types of immunoglobulin (Ig) receptors on their surface. These receptors are also known as B cell receptors (BCRs), and they enable B cells to recognize and bind to antigens. Each B cell has a unique BCR that can recognize a specific antigen.
When B cells encounter an antigen that matches their BCR, they become activated and undergo clonal expansion, where they divide and produce many copies of themselves. Some of these clones differentiate into plasma cells, which secrete large amounts of antibodies into the blood and lymph. These antibodies can circulate throughout the body and bind to the same antigen that triggered the B cell activation. This helps to eliminate the antigen and prevent infection.
Other clones differentiate into memory B cells, which do not secrete antibodies but retain their BCRs. These memory B cells can survive for a long time in the body and provide a rapid and enhanced response if the same antigen is encountered again in the future. This is the basis of immunological memory, which is one of the hallmarks of the adaptive immune system.
B cells can participate in two types of immune responses: primary and secondary. The primary immune response occurs when B cells encounter an antigen for the first time. The secondary immune response occurs when B cells encounter the same antigen again after a period of time. The secondary immune response is faster, stronger, and more specific than the primary immune response, due to the presence of memory B cells. In this article, we will compare and contrast the primary and secondary immune responses in detail.
The following diagram illustrates the difference between a primary and secondary immune response. It shows how B cells are activated by an antigen and differentiate into plasma cells and memory cells. Plasma cells produce antibodies that bind to the antigen and help eliminate it from the body. Memory cells remain in the body for a long time and can quickly respond to the same antigen if it reappears.
(Source: Textbook of Microbiology and Immunology, 2/e, Parija)
The primary immune response occurs when the body encounters an antigen for the first time. It takes several days for the B cells to be activated and produce enough antibodies to fight the infection. The antibody level peaks around 10 to 14 days after exposure and then declines gradually.
The secondary immune response occurs when the body encounters the same antigen again. It is faster and stronger than the primary response because of the presence of memory cells. The memory cells recognize the antigen and rapidly proliferate into plasma cells and more memory cells. The antibody level peaks within 2 to 7 days after exposure and remains high for a longer time.
The secondary immune response provides long-lasting immunity against the antigen. It is the basis of vaccination, which exposes the body to a weakened or inactivated form of an antigen to induce memory cells without causing disease.
The immune system is composed of two types of cells: innate and adaptive. Innate cells are the first line of defense against pathogens and they respond quickly and non-specifically. Adaptive cells are the second line of defense and they respond slowly and specifically. B cells are a type of adaptive cell that produce antibodies, which are proteins that bind to antigens (foreign substances) and neutralize them.
When B cells encounter an antigen for the first time, they undergo a process called activation, which involves clonal expansion and differentiation. Clonal expansion is the rapid multiplication of B cells that have the same antigen receptor. Differentiation is the process by which some activated B cells become plasma cells, which secrete large amounts of antibodies, and some become memory B cells, which store the information about the antigen for future use.
The first exposure to an antigen triggers a primary immune response, which is characterized by a lag phase, a peak phase, and a decline phase. The lag phase is the time between the exposure and the detection of antibodies in the blood. It can last from several days to weeks, depending on the nature and dose of the antigen. The peak phase is the time when the antibody level reaches its maximum. It can last from a few days to weeks, depending on the type and amount of antibodies produced. The decline phase is the time when the antibody level gradually decreases due to the elimination of plasma cells and antibodies.
The primary immune response provides protection against the antigen, but it is not very efficient or long-lasting. However, it prepares the immune system for a faster and stronger response in case of a subsequent exposure to the same antigen. This is called a secondary immune response, which is mediated by memory B cells.
Memory B cells are long-lived cells that can survive for years in the body. They have a high affinity for the antigen and they can quickly recognize and respond to it. When memory B cells encounter the same antigen again, they do not need to undergo activation, but they directly differentiate into plasma cells and secrete large amounts of antibodies. They also undergo clonal expansion and produce more memory B cells.
The secondary immune response is characterized by a shorter lag phase, a higher peak phase, and a longer decline phase than the primary immune response. The lag phase can be as short as a few hours or days, depending on the number and location of memory B cells. The peak phase can be 10 to 100 times higher than the primary immune response, depending on the affinity and class of antibodies produced. The decline phase can last for months or years, depending on the stability and half-life of antibodies.
The secondary immune response provides a more effective and durable protection against the antigen than the primary immune response. It also prevents or reduces the severity of infections caused by related antigens due to cross-reactivity. Cross-reactivity is the ability of antibodies to bind to antigens that share some structural similarities with the original antigen.
In summary, primary and secondary immune responses are two types of adaptive responses mediated by B cells and antibodies. They differ in their kinetics, magnitude, quality, and duration. Primary immune response is slow, weak, short-lived, and specific. Secondary immune response is fast, strong, long-lived, and cross-reactive.
S.N. | Characteristics | Primary Immune Response | Secondary Immune Response |
---|---|---|---|
1. | Definition | The first exposure of an antigen to the immune system | The subsequent exposure of the same antigen to the immune system |
2. | Lag phase | The time between the antigen exposure and the appearance of antibodies in the blood | The time between the antigen exposure and the appearance of antibodies in the blood |
3. | Duration of lag phase | Longer (4-7 days) | Shorter (1-3 days) |
4. | Peak antibody level | Lower | Higher |
5. | Duration of peak antibody level | Shorter (a few weeks) | Longer (several months) |
6. | Type of antibody produced | Mainly IgM, followed by IgG | Mainly IgG, followed by IgM |
7. | Affinity of antibody for antigen | Lower | Higher |
8. | Memory cells formation | Fewer | More |
9. | Memory cells lifespan | Shorter (a few months) | Longer (several years) |
10. | Antigen recognition by B cells | Requires T cell help (T-dependent antigens) or not (T-independent antigens) | Does not require T cell help (memory B cells) |
11. | Antigen presentation by B cells | Requires MHC class II molecules on B cells surface to present antigen to T cells | Does not require MHC class II molecules on memory B cells surface to present antigen to T cells |
12. | Clonal expansion of B cells | Less extensive (fewer plasma cells and memory cells) | More extensive (more plasma cells and memory cells) |
12 differences between Primary and Secondary Immune Response
The primary and secondary immune responses differ in several aspects, such as:
- Time of onset: The primary immune response takes about 4 to 7 days to become effective, while the secondary immune response is rapid and can be activated within hours or days.
- Duration: The primary immune response is short-lived and declines after the elimination of the antigen, while the secondary immune response is long-lasting and can persist for months or years.
- Antibody level: The primary immune response produces a low level of antibodies, while the secondary immune response produces a high level of antibodies that can reach up to 1000 times higher than the primary response.
- Antibody class: The primary immune response mainly produces IgM antibodies, which are the first antibodies to be synthesized, while the secondary immune response mainly produces IgG antibodies, which are the most abundant and versatile antibodies in the serum.
- Antibody affinity: The primary immune response produces antibodies with low affinity, meaning they have a weak binding to the antigen, while the secondary immune response produces antibodies with high affinity, meaning they have a strong binding to the antigen.
- Memory cells: The primary immune response generates a small number of memory B cells, which are long-lived cells that can recognize the same antigen in the future, while the secondary immune response generates a large number of memory B cells, which can quickly differentiate into plasma cells upon re-exposure to the antigen.
- Clonal expansion: The primary immune response involves a limited clonal expansion of B cells, meaning they undergo a few rounds of cell division to produce more antibody-secreting cells, while the secondary immune response involves a massive clonal expansion of B cells, meaning they undergo many rounds of cell division to produce a large number of antibody-secreting cells.
- Somatic hypermutation: The primary immune response involves a low rate of somatic hypermutation, which is a process that introduces random mutations in the antibody genes to increase their diversity and affinity, while the secondary immune response involves a high rate of somatic hypermutation, which results in the generation of antibodies with higher affinity and specificity.
- Class switching: The primary immune response involves a limited class switching, which is a process that changes the constant region of the antibody to produce different classes of antibodies with different functions, while the secondary immune response involves a extensive class switching, which results in the production of various classes of antibodies such as IgG, IgA and IgE.
- Protective immunity: The primary immune response provides a weak protective immunity, meaning it can only partially prevent or reduce the severity of infection by the same antigen, while the secondary immune response provides a strong protective immunity, meaning it can prevent or eliminate infection by the same antigen.
- Inflammation: The primary immune response causes more inflammation and tissue damage, as it involves the activation of complement system and phagocytic cells that release inflammatory mediators, while the secondary immune response causes less inflammation and tissue damage, as it involves the neutralization and opsonization of antigens by antibodies that facilitate their clearance by phagocytic cells.
- Vaccine efficacy: The primary immune response is essential for vaccine efficacy, as it primes the immune system to recognize and respond to a specific antigen, while the secondary immune response is responsible for vaccine efficacy, as it boosts and maintains the protective immunity against the antigen.
These are some of the major differences between primary and secondary immune responses. They illustrate how the adaptive immune system adapts and improves its ability to fight against foreign invaders over time.
- You can use headings to organize the article into sections, such as
## Introduction
,## Primary vs Secondary Immune Response
,## Comparison Table
, etc. - You can use a compact table to display the comparison between primary and secondary immune response, such as:
S.N. | Characteristics | Primary Immune Response | Secondary Immune Response |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Antigen recognition | Requires naive B cells that have not encountered the antigen before | Requires memory B cells that have encountered the antigen before |
2 | Lag phase | Longer (4-7 days) | Shorter (1-3 days) |
3 | Antibody production | Lower and slower | Higher and faster |
... | ... | ... | ... |
- You can use code blocks to display the diagrams from the sources, such as:
Primary and secondary response
(Source: Textbook of Microbiology and Immunology, 2/e, Parija)
Primary response Secondary response
--------------- -----------------
Naive B cell Memory B cell
| |
V V
Antigen recognition Antigen recognition
| |
V V
Activation and differentiation Activation and differentiation
| |
V V
Plasma cells and memory cells Plasma cells and memory cells
| |
V V
Antibody secretion Antibody secretion
Primary response Secondary response
IgM IgG
^ ^
| |
+----+ +----+
| | | |
+----+ +----+
\ / \ /
\/ \/
/\ /\
/ \ / \
+----+ +----+
| | | |
+----+ +----+
Antigen Antigen
```
We are Compiling this Section. Thanks for your understanding.